Tottenham Hotspur are being increasingly linked to Freiburg breakout star striker Igor Matanovic as a potential winter transfer window option, as a January loan is now apparently an option on the table for the Lilywhites. The reasoning behind the interest is actually sensible. See, per transfer insider Ben Jacobs, Matanovic is not Spurs top target at striker, but they would like to make a short term acquisition of him on loan if they cannot sign a preferred target, rather than panic buying someone who isn't good enough.
Because Spurs are so desperate for a striker and because everything else about the team besides a No. 9 is so excellent while their strikers are so abhorrent at scoring goals, especially the only true 9 in the squad in Dominic Solanke, they are actually very vulnerable to a panic buy. Just about anyone is going to look good in comparison to Solanke, but if they sign the wrong player, they are basically going to be stuck with another bad striker for a few more years and a contract they can't get out of.
Igor Matanovic sounds like a bad idea
Solanke is the original panic buy. Spurs lost a legend in Harry Kane and then spent a record 65 million pounds on Solanke after his one fluke 19 goal season for Bournemouth, and he has come nowhere near those numbers since because, well, he was never a good scoring striker at the Premier League level to begin with.
But Igor Matanovic is almost a solution that combines two bad solutions. The first bad solution is signing a striker, like Solanke, who isn't good enough. Spurs want to avoid that, yet Matanovic isn't good enough himself. He started the season hot, but his 4 goals in 9 Bundesliga appearances is hardly the kind of production that will translate to great Premier League success. He's not much of a creator, and while his dribbles completed and fouls drawn are impressive, compared to how many dribbles he takes and how much he loses possession, he's basically a worse version of Omar Marmoush or Mathys Tel on the ball.
The other problem that is arguably bigger is simply doing nothing at all. Signing Matanovic means Spurs would be doing something, but, in actuality, they would be signing a mediocre striker for a few months with no upside after that. And with all due respect, Matanovic isn't the caliber of a short term loan that would pump up Spurs into the top five of the table; he's no Victor Osimhen.
