Tottenham star is battling for his future at the club, pundit claims

A Tottenham Hotspur star is reportedly battling for his future at the club, according to a pundit after the match against West Ham.

Tottenham Hotspur’s recent 4-1 victory over West Ham has brought both jubilation and concern to the North London club, particularly regarding the future of midfielder James Maddison.

While the win showcased Tottenham's attacking prowess, a significant talking point emerged from the match: Maddison's substitution at half-time, which left many questioning his role within the squad.

In a game that saw Spurs come back strongly in the second half, Maddison had been instrumental in the first half, providing a crucial assist for Dejan Kulusevski's equaliser.

However, with the score level at 1-1, manager Ange Postecoglou opted to substitute Maddison for Pape Matar Sarr. This decision raised eyebrows, especially as Maddison appeared visibly upset when leaving the pitch.

His body language during post-match interviews further fueled speculation, as he seemed disengaged and frustrated with the situation.

Tottenham star is battling for his future at the club, pundit claims

Football pundit Tony Cascarino highlighted Maddison’s reaction in his analysis of the game, pointing out that the midfielder might be grappling with his place in the starting XI.

“He’s fighting for his career at Tottenham after a year really,” Cascarino remarked. The ex-player pointed out that although Maddison is an incredibly talented footballer with excellent skills, he’s always done his best work as a key player in the midfield. Now, though, the big question is whether he’s still being given that same important role with Postecoglou in charge.

Cascarino's remarks point to a wider worry about Maddison's place in the team as it evolves. Under Postecoglou, Spurs seem to be embracing a more team-oriented style, focusing on collaboration and fluid play rather than individual flair.

This change might mean Maddison needs to adapt his game, stepping back from the central playmaker role he had at his previous clubs. Instead, he’ll have to figure out how to make a significant contribution within a system that prioritises balance and movement.

Postecoglou defended his decision to substitute Maddison after the match, explaining that it was a tactical choice aimed at injecting energy into the midfield.

“We needed more mobility,” he stated, explaining how Sarr's presence helped Spurs dominate the second half, netting three goals within eight minutes. While the tactical adjustment paid off handsomely, it raises questions about Maddison’s long-term standing in the team.

Former Spurs scout Mick Brown highlighted that Postecoglou isn’t afraid to make difficult choices, which might mean that Maddison’s place in the starting XI isn’t secure for the future.