Stoke City currently have three former Tottenham players in their squad with two of them having moved directly from Spurs to the Brittannia Stadium in 2011. Previously, it was less common for direct transfers to occur, more often the players appeared at both clubs at some period in their careers.
Peter Crouch started his career with the Spurs youth team but moved on to QPR and then played for Portsmouth (twice), Aston Villa, Southampton and Liverpool before following Harry Redknapp from Fratton Park to rejoin Tottenham in July, 2009. He made 73 League appearances for Spurs but only scored twelve goals although it was his goal against Manchester City in May, 2010 that guaranteed Spurs their first season of Champions League football. Ironically, it was his own goal a year later in the same fixture that took City in to the Champions League. It was in Europe that he was most effective when foreign defenders failed to cope with his height and as with England he scored more frequently, scoring 22 international goals from 42 appearances. He scored the only goal against AC Milan in the San Siro but his early sending off against Real Madrid brought Spurs Champions League campaign to a disappointing end at the quarter final stage. He joined Stoke for a fee of £10 million.
Wilson Palacios has struggled with injury since joining Stoke at the same time as Crouch. Spurs received about £6 million for the player who had joined them from Wigan in January, 2009 for £12 million. He made 65 League appearances and scored once against Hull City. In his final season he appeared less frequently in the team as Sandro became more accustomed to English football and competition for places in central midfield became more intense.
Matthew Etherington joined Spurs in a joint deal with Simon Davies from Peterborough United on New Year’s Day, 2000. He was valued at £500,000 but failed to establish himself during his three years at the club. He made 51 League appearances for Spurs (28 as a substitute) – scoring once in the League against Everton and twice in the Cup. He joined West Ham United in August, 2003 as part of the deal which brought Fredi Kanoute to Spurs. In January, 2009 he joined Stoke and has helped the club become established in the Premier League, reach last season FA Cup Final and compete in the Europa League. One of the reasons for Stoke’s disappointing performance at Wembley against Manchester City in the 2011 FA Cup Final was that Etherington had rushed back from injury and was not fully fit. He has played less frequently this season.
A fourth player who is listed as a Stoke player and has Tottenham connections, is Michael Kightly. He was a schoolboy with Spurs but was released and then made a return to top flight football through the non-League game. Stoke signed him from Wolverhampton Wanderers in the summer of 2012 but he is currently on loan with Burnley and helped them to win promotion to the Premier League.
They have also played for Tottenham and Stoke
Jonathan Woodgate has had his career blighted by injury at Leeds United, Newcastle United, Real Madrid, Middlesbrough and Spurs. He joined Spurs from Middlesbrough in January, 2008 for £7.5 million and became an instant hero when he scored the winning goal against Chelsea at Wembley in the Carling Cup Final. That was the highlight of his time with Spurs as he was often out injured and only made 49 League appearances. He played only 15 minutes of football in his final eighteen months at the club. Much time was spent undergoing operations and treatment in an effort to resolve his injury problems. On joining Stoke he played in league matches but has sat out the midweek Cup and European games. He resigned for Middlesbrough in 2012.
Garth Crooks is the last player to move in the opposite direction, coming to Tottenham in the summer of 1980 to join up with Steve Archibald in a striking partnership which would take the team to two FA Cup successes. He became the forgotten man of the 1981 Cup win as Ricky Villa’s goals in the semi-final and final overshadowed his contribution to the success. He signed for £650,000 and moved on to West Brom on a free transfer in August, 1985, having had a period on loan with Manchester United. He scored 48 goals in 125 League appearances for Spurs and 27 Cup and European goals in 57 appearances.
Ian Moores joined Spurs from Stoke in 1976 as they battled against relegation. They failed to avoid the drop but Moores helped the club gain promotion the following year. He scored a hat-trick in the 9 – 0 demolition of Bristol Rovers but the following season, after two years with Tottenham he joined Leyton Orient. Following his retirement he went into coaching but sadly died after illness at the age of 43.
Other players who have played for both clubs but not consecutively, are:Jimmy Robertson scored in the 1967 FA Cup Final win over Chelsea but joined Arsenal eighteen months later and then had five years at Stoke after a time with Ipswich Town.
Ray Evans came through the youth system at Spurs but in the early 1970s struggled to establish himself in the team ahead of Joe Kinnear. He made 133 League appearances at full back but in January, 1975 signed for Millwall. He joined Stoke in 1979 after two years at Fulham.
Tony Parks, the current goalkeeping coach with Spurs and hero of the 1984 UEFA Cup Final win made two appearances for Stoke in 1992. He came through Spurs youth system but in eight years with the club he made only 37 appearances. His big moment came in 1984 when Ray Clemence was injured and he had the opportunity for an extended run in the team which took them to the UEFA Cup Final penalty shoot-out success.Gary Brooke who was substitute for the 1981 and 1982 FA Cup Finals had a loan period at Stoke later in his career after leaving White Hart Lane. Brooke came through the youth system and was a hard tackling midfielder with a powerful shot. A serious car accident threatened his career and restricted his appearances for Spurs.
Paul Stewart and Paul Allen who played in the 1991 FA Cup win over Nottingham Forest both played for Stoke after leaving Tottenham.
Gerard McMahon, a young midfield player who made a few first team appearances following his transfer from Glenavon in Northern Ireland for £100,000 joined Stoke for £450,000 in 1996 after four years at White Hart Lane.
Hans Segers who came to Spurs late in his career as goalkeeping cover and then coach, had time with Stoke in earlier days.
Two older players who played for both clubs – Joe Brough, a half back, who made two appearances for Spurs in their first season in the Football League in 1908. He joined from Stoke City having had a season with them and moved on to Port Vale in 1909.
Charlie Wilson was a centre forward who played for Spurs from 1919 to 1922. He then had six years with Stoke after signing for them in 1925. He scored 27 League goals in 55 appearances for Spurs before joining Huddersfield Town. In his time with Stoke he scored 110 goals in over 150 League appearances.